The Locker

Value Card Buyback

Submission Received.

You're in the next buyback cycle. Bring your cards to The Locker whenever you're ready — we just sent a confirmation email with everything you need to know.

A Headline Service

Value Card Buyback

Turn your stacks of lower-value cards — the $1–$5 kind that don't qualify for consignment — into Headline store credit. Drop them off, we handle the rest.

How It Works

Simple, transparent, and built for the cards that usually just sit in a box.

  1. Submit & drop offFill out the form below, then bring your cards to The Locker.
  2. Weekly buyer cycleOur local bulk buyer visits once a week and prices your stack as a lot.
  3. You get 80%Whatever the buyer pays for your cards, 80% is yours. Headline keeps 20% for handling the process.
  4. Paid in store creditYour payout is added to your Headline account as store credit — spend it online or in store.
80%Your store credit
20%Headline handling
Heads Up

This is not an instant cash offer. Cards are priced on our weekly buyer cycle, and your payout is issued as Headline store credit once the buyer's payment is received. Best for cards roughly in the $1–$5 range.

Your Info

So we can match your cards to you and send your store credit to the right account.

Please enter your full name
Please enter a valid email

Use the same email as your Headline / shopwithheadline.com account — that's where your store credit lands.

Please enter your phone number
Please enter a rough card count

A rough estimate is fine — our team verifies the exact count when you drop off.

The Agreement

The short version of how the program works.

Ready?

Lock In Your Spot.

Then drop your cards at The Locker